Same Sex Marriage Discussions
Same Sex Marriage Discussion Paper
The Christian church’s discussions around the same-sex marriage question have become a central issue dividing those with conservative and liberal views in the church. Many have argued that this is one of the main reasons why church attendance in the 21st Century is in decline.
On 9th July 2016 the United Reformed Church General Assembly made a declaration that, as a denomination, it was unable to adopt a single view on the matter of the marriage of same- sex couples. Since then, it has allowed individual churches to decide on whether to permit the marriage of same-sex couples on their premises or not. The URC was the first mainstream denomination to permit same-sex marriages, although in 2021 the Methodist Conference made the same decision. In 2017 Dursley Tabernacle voted on the subject and, although the majority of church members felt that same-sex marriages should be permitted at Dursley Tabernacle, it was decided not to proceed at that time because the majority was small. It was agreed that the subject should be revisited after seven years and so now, in 2024, we return to the discussion.
The topic is difficult for three reasons:
- Over time there have been changes in scientific understanding of gender and sexuality.
- Over time and in different cultures there are different views about the nature and purpose of marriage.
- There are different translations and different interpretations of a small number of key passages in the Bible.
Those who do not support same-sex marriage tend to argue that 2,000 years of church teaching has not allowed same-sex marriage and that marriage can only exist between a man and a woman. Many believe that any kind of same-sex sexual attraction is not normal or natural and is not in keeping with the will of God. They argue that certain passages in the Bible condemn any expression of a homoerotic nature.
Those who do support same-sex marriage tend to argue that just as scientific knowledge has challenged some of our thinking about God’s methods of creation, our better scientific knowledge now challenges traditional teaching on the topic of same-sex attraction and what is normal or natural. They suggest that there are many inconsistencies and contradictions in the Bible and that the Bible passages in question need to be translated with care and understood in the specific social and cultural contexts of the ancient world, which do not necessarily apply to people today.
Latest News
Bible Day with Dr Alison Gray
BIBLE DAY At Dursley Tabernacle Saturday 2nd November 10am to 4pm Dr Alison Gray, Tutor in Old Testament Language, Literature & Theology at Westminster College, Cambridge is coming to lead a day looking at some topics from the Old Testament. Alison has energetic and creative presentations, bringing the scriptures alive for today. In the morning, […]
Walk Thru The Bible
Walk Through the New Testament Saturday 12th October 10am to 4pm at Dursley Tabernacle An experience that will forever change the way you view your Bible. An interactive and engaging teaching event that uncovers the Big Picture of the New Testament – Matthew to Revelation. An encouraging way to consolidate prior Bible knowledge and help fill […]